‘Space for Reason and Debate is shrinking in India’

‘Space for Reason and Debate is shrinking in India’

Calcutta (Jan 1) Attempts made to “fabricate and distort history” is a terror of a different nature, , says Professor K M Shrimali,  president general of Indian History Congress, expressing concern over the shrinking space for reason and debate in the country, reports PTI.

The sole agenda behind RSS-BJP trying to rewrite history is to create a so-called  Hindu nation, where minorities are treated as second-class citizens, he said.

Reason and debate have become the biggest casualties in the Sangh Parivar’s interpretation of history, the  professor rued.

“It is matter of concern that the space for reason and debate is shrinking in India. We have never witnessed such a disturbing trend. Those with little knowledge about history are trying to fabricate and thrust their idea. It is a terror of a different nature,” Shrimal, former history professor of Delhi University told PTI.

The RSS and the BJP are determined to divide the nation on religious grounds, Shrimali said, adding that history is a discipline of reason and cannot be written with fabricated truths, imagination or myth-making.

“There are ways of understanding mythology… Not everything which is part of mythology is history… But you don’t enter into arguments, you try to bully people. That’s not the way to write history,” he said.

The historian also explained that Hindutva and Hinduism are different concepts with the former being a political ideology.

SEE ALSO  Congress defends Modi, when Trump mocks!

Shrimali said Hindutva is being used as a tool to access power. The uproar over Ayodha temple and the film, Padamavati, is aimed at consolidation of Hindu votes.

Reacting to a RSS-BJP criticism that a distorted version of history is being taught in India by the “Left and liberal historians”, Shrimali said historians don’t need to take lessons on nationalism from those “who had surrendered before the British during the independence movement”.

He also said that the party in power is trying to obliterate the contributions and legacies of the Mughal Empire. He, however, expressed confidence on the “functioning of the minds” of Indian people in their attempts to resist fabricated history.

Shrimali’s view found resonance in eminent historian Irfan Habib, who said history depends on “events of facts” and any attempt to invent facts will be treated as fiction.

Slamming the rising political intolerance and the recent killings of rationalists Narendra Dabholkar, Govind Pansare, M M Kalburgi, Habib said an atmosphere of fear is prevailing in the country, where these murders are grisly reminders of an ongoing campaign against the freedom of thought, speech and expression.

One Response to "‘Space for Reason and Debate is shrinking in India’"

  1. SEEMA KUMARI   January 2, 2018 at 1:19 pm

    We have come to the stage where we can say that our country is democratic but in reality I feel that we are living in a fake democratic country where electoral parties are busy making their own history of the country for their personal benefits.They are not playing fairly in election,they are encouraging hatred among people. Day by day the situation is getting worse and we the citizen’s of India really need to look after it.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.